Testimonial Quotes What Our Clients are Saying

Overall it was better than expected. DJ restored our faith in the profession. A fact proven given what I consider the improper or unethical conduct of the buyers realator. DJ stayed true and represented us fairly. We respect his knowledge of the differences of urban vs. rural properties, and his faith in us. We are so appreciative for having him as our representative.

Larry P

Featuring David "DJ" Dietrich

Mitch was such a pleasure to work with. He was responsive, caring, thorough, funny and so much more. We felt like we really lucked out by having him help us purchase our property. It was not easy purchasing from Amish folks and he was on top of everything, kept things light hearted and went above and beyond for us. We always recommend our family and friends to use Whitetail Properties when they look for land because of our wonderful experience with Mitch.

Kelly W

Featuring Mitch Serlin

"I have really enjoyed working with Ann and Dave White of Whitetail Properties Real Estate, LLC. It is difficult to find a real estate agent who specializes in selling mountain property. Ann and Dave are very knowledgeable on the uniqueness of marketing mountain property and guiding the sale all the way through the closing. They were quick to get the property listing out there on the market with a wide exposure to potential buyers. They were very proactive in keeping us informed of how things were progressing through the process and what we needed to do to help the sale along. Whenever I had questions they were quick to respond. They are true professionals and I highly recommend them to anyone selling mountain/recreation property."

Kent C

Featuring Ann White

"Just wanted to thank you for all the help in the purchase of our new home in Sullivan, Indiana. Jeremy Whitkanack was absolutely wonderful in all aspects of selecting a property, submitting an offer, and navigating the closing process as well as after the closing. He was extremely accessible, prompt in responding to emails and texts, knowledgeable about the area and thoughtful and understanding in helping us with the many questions we had about the property and the buying process. I would highly recommend Jeremy to anyone searching for a new home."

Chris & Pam F

Featuring Jeremy Whitkanack

"I want to take a moment to commend Tony Chrisco. He was great to work with from beginning to end. When we first listed the property with Tony, my husband was still alive and able to visit with Tony regarding our property. I felt good that after meeting with Tony, my husband John, felt Tony would be a man of integrity and someone we could trust as we would go through the process of selling. John passed away in November 2023 but Tony continued to keep me informed and walked me step by step through the process of selling. I would highly recommend Tony as a realtor to anyone selling hunting or farm property."

Nancy P

Featuring Tony Chrisco

"My husband John and I recently made what we consider one of our most important purchases since we wed in 2011. John lost his father to cancer when he was 19 years old. He and his father had a remarkably close relationship, spending much of their time outdoors fishing or driving the gravel roads of the Wildlife Management Area. Our home is bordered by much of this land that offers him such fond memories. John built the home we live in here, on ground he and his dad cleared by hand. His family has roots in this KY holler going back generations. Countless times John has mentioned how he wished it would come up for sale, knowing it would never happen. A few survey markings spotted on our way home one day followed by some web searching led us to find Whitetail Properties and Matt Young. He was so quick to respond to our questions and I never had a shortage of them. We never had to wonder if he was going to return a call or message. When we decided to put in an offer he was on top of things and kept us informed throughout each step and let us know what to expect next. We had questions about finance companies, surveys, titles, borders, you name it... the knowledge this guy brings to the table is such a comfort. Never was there an encounter or conversation with Matt that we were not fully satisfied with the outcome or answers we received. Professionalism is important and we found that in our dealings with Matt Young. Land is a big investment and decision to make, this was an easy one for us. Purchasing the land around us ensures the place we call home, which reminds my sweet husband of time with his father will not change. It ensures the property around us will not ‘fill” with subdivisions muddying those memories. We are eager to work with Matt and Whitetail Properties in the future to secure more of this land. The smile on my husband’s face throughout this purchase is priceless. We could not be happier with the quality customer service we received. Thank you, Matt Young, for making this experience one we cannot wait to repeat!"

John & Sheila M

Featuring Matt Young

So easy and professional. I worked with Jay remotely as I live in Montana and sold a property in Indiana. Would definitely work with him again!

Kelley M

Featuring Jay Minor

“Jim was always willing to put on his boots no matter the weather and walk a property or crawl under a basement to make sure it's dry. He'll keep showing you properties till you find the right one. He goes that extra mile to make sure you're happy.”

Robert B

Featuring James Klossner

"My experience with Cade Taylor was excellent. From the first time I spoke on the phone to him about the property until the day we closed on it, he was wonderful. Cade has so much knowledge about what he does. He is very efficient and is very comfortable to talk to. He is very polite, honest, answers whenever we had questions, and I totally trusted him. Again, thanks for a job well done, Cade."

Leonard & Marsha G

Featuring Cade Taylor

"Brent was great to work with - he worked with us taking pictures inside and out of our home/property. He was great at giving us suggestions on what needed improved for a good sale. Brent is very personable - he stayed in touch with us through text or phone calls and answered our many questions. We would do business with him again if the time arose."

Lynita S

Featuring Brent Reneau